Let the Mediocre One In?
Reassessing beloved genre films is always a touchy subject. Oftentimes, a film is critically acclaimed, a lot of people say they love it, and it enters the public discourse as a “great” film. From that point forward it usually takes on a life of its own. A “great” horror film is something you are supposed to worship at the alter of, regardless of whether or not you like it. This is certainly true for some films, others not so much. Sometimes a movie is released during a time of relative subpar activity and quality. It can turn an “ok” film into a “great” film simply by the lack of quality surrounding it. Once these films enter the “Great” stratosphere, it’s hard to shake that label. It becomes incumbent upon a critic to reassess and reevaluate and say “Wait a minute, maybe we were a little off base with our proclamations of excellence.”
I’m still debating whether or not to see the newly reformed Hammer Films’ first wide release, Let Me In, a remake of Tomas Alfredson’s widely acclaimed 2008 Swedish flick Let the Right One In. Unfortunately for Hammer, their remake absolutely bombed at the box office (doing worse than Case 39, a film that was made in 2006 and was thrown into theaters to try and make a quick buck, capitalizing on the October spirit) but it made me wonder: how good is this movie, really? With that in mind I went back and took a look at the original film which has really gone without any serious critical interpretation. It’s sort of coasted on its “greatness” since its release (even winning 4 Splatcademy Awards including Best Film a couple years back). Let’s see how it holds up…
Filed under: Commentary, DVD, Foreign | 12 Comments »












